66 pages 2 hours read

The Green Mile

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 1996

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 4, Chapters 5-9Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 4: The Bad Death of Eduard Delacroix

Chapter 5 Summary

Once the guards manage to bring Delacroix’s body to the gurney, Paul stops Brutal from punching Percy. Brutal demands to know why he should not hurt Percy for what he did. Paul explains that should anything injurious happen to Percy, they will all be fired, and Percy will still be around. Percy claims innocence, declaring he didn’t not know the sponge was supposed to be wet, which Paul senses is a lie Percy has rehearsed. Curtis Anderson, filling in for Warden Moores, arrives to tell the guards that all the witnesses are upset. The guards reassure Anderson that all will be fine and that Percy is the one responsible for the error in the execution. Percy cannot protest as this reason is far preferable to the truth—that Percy omitted wetting the sponges on purpose. Paul tells Anderson that Percy will be filing for a transfer soon. Brutal adds that Percy will be taking sick days until that happens. 

Chapter 6 Summary

Back at E Block, William Wharton sings a crass song about Delacroix’s execution, which deeply annoys Paul. Coffey is crying in his cell, mourning Delacroix’s death. Mr. Jingles is nowhere to be found. At the end of the chapter, Paul thinks of walking away but instead calls out Coffey’s full name, gets on one knee, and undoes one of his shoes.

Chapter 7 Summary

When Paul returns home from Delacroix’s execution, he cries into Janice’s arms. Janie suggests they have sex, to help soothe him. Paul falls asleep, dreaming of Delacroix, Melinda Moores, and Coffey. In his dream, Coffey is holding one of the twin girls in the crook of each arm. In his fists are the wooden spool and Paul’s shoe. He says again, “I couldn’t help it,” and, “I tried to take it back, but it was too late” (313). This time, Paul understands that these words are not an admission of his crimes, but rather his lamentation for not being able to save the girls. 

Chapter 8 Summary

The next morning, Paul receives a call from Hal Moores, who has heard reports of the faulty execution and Percy’s transfer. Moores reveals that Percy should be transferred to Briar Ridge within a month, which Paul privately laments is too long of a stretch of time. Paul asks about Melinda’s condition. Moores reveals that Melina is not doing well and that the brain tumor is making her swear. Paul offers words of consolation before hanging up. Janice inquires after Melinda, and Paul reports on her progress. Janice points out that Paul has a look on his face that seems to be contemplating something that could potentially get him into trouble. She excuses herself so that Paul can make a phone call, presumably to set out to do the very thing she suspects.

Chapter 9 Summary

Paul calls Brutal, Dean, and Harry over to his house for lunch. When they arrive, he tells them his plan to have Coffey cure Melinda of her brain tumor. They go over the risks, including what might happen if Percy tells on them. Paul assures them that Percy will not tell. He also says that the best plan may be to figure out a way to bring Coffey to Melinda as opposed to bringing Melinda to E Block. Brutal, Dean, and Harry are skeptical at first, and are concerned about losing their jobs. However, Paul convinces them that saving Melinda’s life will be atonement for their complicity in Delacroix’s gruesome death. Harry offers his pickup truck to help shuttle Coffey to Melinda. The rest of the guards are still concerned about Coffey being a murderer and that he may pose a threat to their lives on the road. Paul assures them of Coffey’s innocence and sets out to prove it at the end of the chapter by telling them about a test he conducted with the inmate using his shoe.

In later chapters, Paul reveals to the other guards that since Coffey was unable to tie the laces of his shoe, the inmate could not be responsible for luring the Detterick dog out of his doghouse during the murders using sausages from his lunch pack as suspected. He elaborates that the lunch pack was found tied neatly in Coffey’s pocket, which meant that he could not have taken the sausages out of the pack to lure the dog and tied it back up so carefully. As Coffey’s lunch pack was a large piece of incriminating evidence for the sheriff department, Paul believes that his shoe test supports Coffey’s innocence.

Chapters 5-9 Analysis

The death of Delacroix sets into motion Paul’s attempts towards atonement. While Paul remained uncertain prior to Delacroix’s death, the horror of the prisoner’s execution and Percy’s terrible abuse of power persuade him to take a more active stance in determining Coffey’s innocence. It also fuels his plan to have Coffey heal Warden Moores’ wife of her brain tumor. In order to atone, Paul insists that he and the guards need to save Melinda, to make up for Delacroix’s death. The guards are hesitant, since they are still convinced that Coffey is a murderer. However, in these chapters, Paul grows surer of his belief in Coffey’s innocence. For instance, in a dream, Paul hears Coffey recite the words he uttered during his arrest, “I couldn’t help it” and “I tried to take it back, but it was too late” (313). While he has heard Coffey recite iterations of these words before, he understands now that the statements are not an admission of guilt, remarking, “And this time, in my dream, I understood him” (313). In his dream, he finally realizes that Coffey’s reference to “help” is a reference to his healing power and not an uncontrollable urge to kill.

In Chapter 6, Paul tests Coffey’s innocence by tasking the inmate to tie the laces of his shoe. When Coffey is unable to, Paul determines that the inmate could not have been the one responsible for killing the Detterick dog as suspected. According to the sheriff department, Coffey had lured the dog out of his dog house using sausages from his lunch pack, which was evidence used to incriminate him. However, Coffey could not have untied and tied the strings around his lunch pack to take out the sausages as he did not know how to tie a knot. This proves that a large piece of evidence used against Coffey is invalid.

Chapter 7 skips ahead to after this revelation, when Paul returns home to Janice. There, he figures out that Coffey’s words upon capture (“I couldn’t help it” and “I tried to take it back, but it was too late”) were not his admission to killing the Detterick twins. Rather, Coffey was mourning that he was not able to save the girls through his healing power. This revelation would not be possible without Delacroix’s death as a propelling force for Paul to investigate further into Coffey’s case. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 66 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 9,150+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools